The home-sharing platform took drastic measures to prevent violence in the capital — but at what cost?

When Alex Dodds started reaching out to local Washington, DC, Airbnb hosts last week asking them to take down their listings and cancel existing reservations ahead of the presidential inauguration, she had hoped the house-sharing company would wave cancellation fines.
Dodds was working on behalf of ShutDownDC, a community organizing group that reached out to the hosts of 3,400 listings, intending to avoid a repeat of violence not only in the Capitol but in the surrounding communities. DC residents reported harassment, vandalism, and other terrifying behavior by aggressive Trump supporters who participated in the storming of the Capitol that resulted in at least 5 deaths and 100 arrests so far. A number of perpetrators were from out of town and stayed at Airbnbs.
Airbnb has said that it has since identified and banned numerous individuals on its platform who were involved in criminal activity at the Capitol. And much to Dodds surprise, the company took the more drastic measure on Wednesday of canceling all DC reservations for inauguration week. In doing so, the company took a clear stand on what was and was not permissible on its platform.
Its refreshing to see a huge corporate actor recognize that their actions have consequence in our communities, Dodds told Recode.
Its also a shift thats happening all over the tech landscape as companies perhaps goaded by newfound enlightenment or, more likely, the prospect of government intervention are being more assertive about what happens on their platforms. Social media companies including Facebook and Twitter, after long claiming neutrality or making exceptions for the sake of news value, kicked Trump off their sites and banned other dangerous users. Amazon pushed right-wing social media alternative Parler, feared to be the next platform coordinating violence, off the internet by refusing to host it on its servers. It remains to be seen how effective these actions are, but it does represent a change in how tech companies view themselves.
Its interesting to think about the role of these platforms in todays age compared to version 1.0, when many of these platforms were just saying, Hey, were not responsible, were just connecting people, David Hsu, professor of management at University of Pennsylvanias Wharton School, told Recode. As a society, were holding them to a higher standard in terms of understanding the possible consequences and how theyll be used.
For the companies themselves, these actions are calculated business decisions. Airbnb is balancing some lost customers and revenue with preserving the trust and safety of the rest of the guests and hosts on its platform issues its dealt with over and over and has since taken a stronger stance on. Indeed, the company made a similar move early in the Covid-19 pandemic, when it allowed guests to cancel without penalization, upsetting many hosts but ultimately curtailing Airbnbs involvement in the spread of the coronavirus.
These issues post a big risk in terms of safety of guests and safety of property and of hosts, said Rajkumar Venkatesan, a business professor at the University of Virginia. Its mission critical for their long-term survival and growth.
Airbnb, which promised to cover what hosts would have made in lost DC reservations, would not provide a number for how many reservations were cancelled or the cost, so well hazard a guess.
For Trumps inauguration four years ago, Airbnb estimated that more than 15,000 people booked rentals in the DC area, more than 10 times the amount that attended Obamas second inauguration in 2013. At the time, Airbnb said Inauguration Day 2017 itself will be the biggest single night ever for Airbnb and the District of Columbia. The median listing price in the area was $129, according to a CNET piece at the time.
Assuming 2017 prices and attendance, that would have meant about $2 million in gross bookings revenue a night that Airbnb will have to reimburse. Additionally, the company will miss out on the fees it normally accrues. That should amount to roughly 13 percent or $260,000 a night, if you look at the companys revenue relative to gross bookings so a loss of a little over $2.2 million each day and roughly $15 million for the week.
DC lawmakers and officials have been asking that people not travel due to new threats of violence ahead of the inauguration and the pandemic. Additionally, investigators from the US House of Representatives have asked travel companies to institute plans to ensure that your services are not being used to facilitate violence or domestic terrorism. So its anyones guess how many reservations actually had to be cancelled. Still, experts say the price whatever it is is worth it.
I think this action of Airbnb first shows the social responsibility of the company, Xinyu Cao, assistant professor of marketing at NYU Stern, said. It enhances the brand image of Airbnb, which benefits the company in the long run.
I think they gain more as a brand taking a stand on something that doesnt cost them that much, said Hsu, the Wharton professor. When you look at the value of the brand, its many multiples of that, he added. Its less than a drop in the bucket.
Airbnb is worth about $108 billion. It spent $712 million on marketing in 2019, the last full year of available data. So $15 million isnt a huge deal in the scheme of things.
Airbnb has put an increasing emphasis on safety, after its share of safety nightmares from both the guest and host side of its business.
Issues have ranged from violence to prostitution to fraud. In a similar move, the company removed users who were trying to book places to stay for the white supremacist rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, in 2017. In 2019, five people were shot and killed at an Airbnb mansion party. The company since put a ban on big parties at its locations by capping guests at 16. That same year, Vice uncovered a nationwide bait-and-switch scam in which hosts gouged guests for higher prices. Ahead of its IPO, Airbnb committed $150 million to safety initiatives, including verifying all of its 7 million listings, in hopes of preventing such problems in the future.
Many of us in this industry over the last 10 years are going from a hands-off model where the internet is an immune system to realizing thats not really enough, Airbnb CEO Brian Chesky said at the New York Timess DealBook conference at the time. We have to take more responsibility for the stuff on our platform. This has been a gradual, maybe too gradual, transition for our industry.
We cant know how much Airbnbs safety measures will actually affect what happens in the next few days, but it seems quite clear that, at least from a PR perspective, its a good move.
Support Vox’s explanatory journalism
Every day at Vox, we aim to answer your most important questions and provide you, and our audience around the world, with information that empowers you through understanding. Voxs work is reaching more people than ever, but our distinctive brand of explanatory journalism takes resources. Your financial contribution will not constitute a donation, but it will enable our staff to continue to offer free articles, videos, and podcasts to all who need them. Please consider making a contribution to Vox today, from as little as $3.